Recent reporting found that approximately 51% of homeowners’ claims handled by USAA and affiliated insurers closed without payment in 2025, according to a new analysis that has prompted Zooby Home Exteriors to urge San Antonio homeowners to inspect their roofs before filing claims. The figure, which does not necessarily indicate wrongful denials, underscores the complexity of insurance claims and the financial risks homeowners face after storm damage.
Zooby Home Exteriors, a San Antonio roofing company, published an article titled “USAA Closed 51% of Homeowners’ Claims Without Payment. Before You File, Find Out What Your Roof Actually Needs,” explaining why claims close without payment and what homeowners should consider. USAA has stated that after accounting for circumstances such as damage below the deductible or policy exclusions, fewer than 6% of its homeowners claims were denied without payment. However, the high percentage of claims closed without payment raises concerns for homeowners navigating the aftermath of hailstorms, which are a growing threat in the United States.
A July 2026 New York Times report, “Inside the United States’ Billion-Dollar Blind Spot,” examined the rising cost of hail damage and the difficulty in predicting it. For San Antonio homeowners, the implications are clear: storm damage can become a significant financial burden, especially when repair costs fall below a percentage-based wind or hail deductible.
Zooby emphasizes the importance of a professional roof inspection before filing a claim. Inspections can identify visible damage, such as loose shingles, granule loss, or damaged flashing, but also reveal underlying issues like water intrusion or age-related deterioration. The inspection answers what the roof needs, while the insurance policy determines what is covered. Zooby does not determine whether a claim must be paid.
A critical factor is the wind and hail deductible, often a percentage of the home’s insured value. For a home insured for $350,000, a 2% deductible equals $7,000. If an insurance carrier approves $6,500 in covered repairs, the homeowner receives no payment because the approved amount is below the deductible. The Texas Department of Insurance provides a similar example in its consumer guidance, explaining that when a home has a $7,500 percentage deductible and needs $6,500 in repairs, the policy does not pay.
“The percentage on the declarations page can look small,” said Zubiate of Zooby. “Once it is converted into dollars, the homeowner may discover that the deductible is several thousand dollars. That number can completely change the claim decision.” Zooby encourages homeowners to calculate their deductible in dollars before storm damage creates pressure to act quickly.
Hail is one of the most expensive severe weather threats in the U.S., with annual losses routinely exceeding $10 billion, according to the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety. Damage from a single hailstorm in a major city can reach $1 billion. “Hail is not only a roofing issue. It can become a household financial issue,” Zubiate said. “A homeowner may know they have insurance but not realize how large the deductible could be until after the storm.”
Zooby examines this impact in “The $7,000 Hail Surprise: What San Antonio Homeowners Should Know Before the Next Storm.” The condition of the roof, severity of damage, policy terms, and deductible size all affect the outcome. A roof may already be weakened by heat, UV exposure, wind, age, or previous storms before a new hail event.
Not all damage requires full roof replacement. Limited damage may be repairable by replacing shingles or fixing flashing. If repair costs are below the deductible, filing a claim may yield no payment. For widespread damage or deterioration, replacement may be necessary. “Before a homeowner creates a claim record or commits to replacing the roof, they should know whether the problem can be repaired,” Zubiate said.
Policy terms also matter. Replacement cost coverage pays current repair or replacement costs minus the deductible, while actual cash value subtracts depreciation. Some policies have roof payment schedules, age-based reductions, or cosmetic damage exclusions. The Texas Department of Insurance home insurance guide explains that claim payments may be reduced by depreciation and deductible. Homeowners should review their policy and consult their agent to understand how terms apply.
Zooby advises homeowners to inspect their roof, estimate repair costs, and understand their deductible and policy before filing a claim. The Texas Department of Insurance recommends finding the deductible and obtaining repair estimates, noting that filing a claim may affect premiums or discounts. A homeowner who understands these factors is better equipped to decide whether to contact the carrier, pay for repairs, or consider other options.
Zooby offers services including repair, Zoobification (a treatment for qualifying asphalt shingle roofs that are aging but still serviceable), and full roof replacement. Zoobification is not for concealing damage or extending a roof that should be replaced. Zooby provides a limited credit warranty for Zoobification, applying a credit toward future replacement if needed, subject to warranty terms. Financing options are also available for necessary work.
Zooby reminds homeowners that Texas law prohibits roofing contractors from waiving, absorbing, or rebating insurance deductibles. The Texas Department of Insurance warns that deductible-waiver offers may involve inflated invoices or other improper arrangements. Homeowners should be cautious of promises of free roofs or waived deductibles.
This news story relied on content distributed by Newsworthy.ai. Blockchain Registration, Verification & Enhancement provided by NewsRamp™. The source URL for this press release is Zooby Urges San Antonio Homeowners to Inspect Roofs Before Filing Insurance Claims After Report Finds 51% of USAA Claims Closed Without Payment.